| HERODOTUS(c.484 - 425 BC) |
shared views / approaches |
THUCYDIDES(c.460 - 400 BC) |
| |
History should be scientific - not mythical. |
|
| |
History should be critical of sources & evidence. |
|
| |
History should attempt to separate the true from the false. |
|
| A critical attitude to evidence. |
| Summarizes the dramatic change in intellectual culture at this time, especially in Athens. |
|
VERY critical & selective attitude to evidence. Raised issues of a) fallibility of human memory, and b) prejudice. |
| Wrote about the Persian Wars in his Histories - events in the relatively near past. |
Wrote about the Peloponnesian War because he had lived through it. |
| Written to be read aloud, for hearing. |
Written for re-reading and studying |
| Homeric style - still essentially part of the oral tradition |
Forensic in style. |
| Written to retell and record stories and traditions. |
Written to be a possession for all time, to be appreciated fully only outside the context of a live recitation. |
 |
However, BOTH were dependent on the oral as their primary
source of evidence
|
 |
| H. covered broad bands of time space, Greek and non-Greek
affairs. |
|
therefore, T. limited himself to contemporary history, that which he'd seen/heard for himself - or at most, first hand interviews with reliable witnesses. |